
Believing Christ
This past week Grace Point discussed legalism. Since this is a Protestant concept, for those of you who may be wondering what this is, let me explain:
strict conformity to the letter of the law rather than it’s spirit (Onelook.com)
Now, personally, I can find simiular teaching (minus the label) in LDS teachings – that God likes a cheerful giver (rather than one who gives with expectations). Since I know Barbie reads my blogs – I’ll toss the question out – does the Catholic Church have a teaching regarding legalism? Is this truly something unique to Protestants?
Regardless of what name it goes by – the basic teaching, that God wants us to respond to Him in love and obediance rather than grudingly or to measure oneself with God is the same. I know that I have battled legalism before – inside the LDS church and inside Grace Point. Legalism is not defined by the church, but by it’s adherents.
I disagree with those who oppose church’s with rules – regardless if those opposed view those rules as silly or un-needed. For this blog, even though I do not personally take the Bible as inerrant, let’s do so for the sake of equal discussion. God is a god of order, not of choas – Jesus Himself stated, “Every kingdom divided against itself will be ruined, and every city or household divided against itself will not stand” (Matthew 12:25, Luke 11:17, Mark 3:25). Further, Jesus Himself stated, “If you want to enter life, obey the commandments,” (Matthew 19:17).
Here’s the deal – sure there are Protestant churches that have some strict rules, having never been apart of them, I cannot speak to their reasoning. However, having been LDS and having a dear friend who is Catholic, I can speak to churches claiming authority – something Protestant churches lack. Sure, Protestants can and do claim “Christ in me” and that is clear enough authority given certain passages of scripture. I understand that, I will respect it – I do not agree with it.
In contrast, churches such as the Catholic church, LDS church, and possibly even the SDA (Seventh Day Adventist) church claim authority from God. As such, when rules as passed down from the Prophet (LDS) or the Pope (Catholic) these rules are directly from God. This isn’t silly, “Wear purple on Thursdays or go to hell,” this is, “Because alcohol in great quanities is bad for the body, this covenant is for the weakest of the Saints and therefore do not drink alcohol.” There is a vast difference. One is for the betterment of the entire body or congregation of that church whereas the other obviously has no temporal or eternal benefits.
When the LDS church passes something down from the Prophet, it is directly coming from God for the betterment of His people. It is up to us then, to decide whether or not to obey. We do not have to obey, we have agency to choose to obey or not. This raises the question – why would anyone join the LDS or Catholic church and not want to obey, not believe the Prophet, not adhere to the beliefs of the Church?
Legalism comes into play when someone follows only the letter of the law and not the spirit of the law. However, I have to sit and ask myself, at what point is this a bad thing? For example, Steve and I did not want to pay tithing when we first became LDS, however we finally obeyed because it was a commmandment of God’s even though we really did not want to, from this obediance came a testimony of tithing. Should obediance only be when we want to obey? Isn’t obediance even more profound when we don’t want to obey?
At the end of the day, it isn’t Grace Point or the LDS church’s faults if I become legalistic while attending their services, it is only my own fault. I strongly dislike (to put it mildly) when people describe whole churches as legalistic – what makes the church legalistic? The church or the body of that church? A church cannot exist without members.
When I was LDS, I obeyed the laws of God passed down through the scriptures and through the prophets because of the great sacrifice of my Savior. I often recalled the night when the great sacrifice that Jesus had laid down for me – and everyone – and how broken I was, how humbled I was, how I longed to live a life of obediance and love to Him.
For those who question legalism within churches claiming authority – I strongly recommend The Parable of the Bicycle by Stephen Robinson. It is an amazing, yet simple story explaining through a parable of a father and daughter why people choose to live a life in obediance to God. It’s not legalism – it’s broken humility wanting to serve the Savior. And it’s beautiful.